Eternal Bliss – Owners’ hopes dashed by Court of Appeal

Eternal Bliss – Owners’ hopes dashed by Court of Appeal | BDM Blog | BDM Law

Regular followers of our blog will recall our report on this case back in September 2020. For those who missed it, please follow this link.

In short, the Court of Appeal allowed Charterers’ appeal, albeit on assumed facts. Lord Justice Males construed the term “demurrage” widely as encompassing the whole of the damages arising from a charterer’s failure to complete cargo operations within the agreed laytime. It was wide enough, he said, to include a claim for damages for deterioration of the cargo provided that this was the sole result of a failure to complete cargo operations within the stated time.

This case is highly pertinent to the carriage of perishable cargoes such as soy beans. Those cargoes are often carried on long voyages in high temperatures. Any delays in loading or discharging can make all the difference. Whilst Owners still have their Hague Visby Rule defences to cargo claims, it is a fact of life that such defences do not always protect them in certain jurisdictions. It follows that Owners who settle those claims are now back to square one when it comes to bringing a claim against Charterers if the cargo deterioration arose solely as a result of delays in loading or discharge.

It is too early to say whether the case will end up in the Supreme Court but, for the moment at least, this is a victory for voyage charterers.

The full case report is available online by clicking here.

BDM is a specialist shipping law firm offering high quality legal advice and representation at a reasonable price. Please follow us on social media by clicking below.

Other Recent Blogs

  • Anti Suit Injunctions What are they and when can you get one | BDM Blog | BDM Law
    March 6, 2024

    Anti Suit Injunctions – What are they and when can you get one?

    Recently, we have been advising clients on a possible anti-suit injunction (ASI) against proceedings commenced in breach of an exclusive jurisdiction clause. On the back of that, we felt it might be useful to release this blog to shed more light on these injunctions, in part[...]

    Read more >
  • Red Sea To go or not to go | BDM Blog | BDM Law
    February 21, 2024

    Red Sea: To go or not to go?

    The world is adjusting to the new reality of ships refusing to run the risk of being targeted by missiles launched by Houthi rebels. Over 50 ships have now been targeted with some seriously damaged. So far, no crew have been killed or injured. However, the risks remain. It[...]

    Read more >
  • BDM partners ranked once again in Who's Who Legal Transport 2024 | BDM Blog | BDM Law
    February 19, 2024

    BDM partners ranked once again in “Who’s Who Legal: Transport 2024”

    Our founding partners have once again been listed as among the world’s leading shipping law practitioners in the Who’s Who Legal: Transport 2024 report. Congratulations to David, Nick and Bob! They commented: “We are very happy to be again recognized in this public[...]

    Read more >
+44 203 968 0500
+44 7887 710 950