Office: +44 203 968 0500
24/7 Emergency Response: +44 7887 710 950
Select Page

Latest twist in the Brilliante Virtuoso – claim struck out due to Owners failure to give disclosure

It is rare for an owner to allow his claim to be struck out for failure to disclose evidence. However, that is exactly what has happened in the latest twist of long running insurance battle between the owners and insurers of the Brilliante Virtuoso.

By way of background, the Brillante Virtuoso became a constructive total loss after pirates allegedly detonated an explosive device on the vessel as it transited the Gulf of Aden in July 2011. The owners’ insurers declined the total loss claim alleging wilful misconduct and the case ended up in the Commercial Court. One of the allegations made was that owners conspired with the charterers in a fraudulent scheme involving the bills of lading so as to deceive the Chinese authorities into charging a lower import duty. Readers of our blog will recall the recent “DC Merwestone” case dealing with the use of a fraudulent device in an insurance claim and insurers looking to decline claims are now very hot on looking for fraud or misconduct so as to avoid having to pay claims.

The Brilliante Virtuoso is such a case. It is clear that the insurers had suspicions about the claim at the outset and, as part of disclosure process, the judge ordered the managers together with Mr Marios Iliopoulos, the ultimate beneficial owner of the ship, to hand over documents stored on the managers’ computer systems. This led to various requests for time and applications to limit the scope of the request but, ultimately, the owners decided not to comply with the order. They would not even release their computer records to their own solicitors. One can only speculate as to what might have been in the owners’ computer systems and how this might have affected the claim but, in view of the failure to comply with the order, the judge felt that he had no alternative but to strike out the owners’ claim.

The excuses put forward for not disclosing the records requested were somewhat bizarre and Mr Iliopoulos’ version of events was branded a fabrication by the judge. There is also a suggestion of some skulduggery in Greece with criminal complaints being filed and suggestions of misconduct on the part of the insurers’ lawyers and consultants. The judge noted that the evidence produced in relation to those proceedings was likely to have been created by representatives of the owners with a view of building a defamation case in Greece against the insurers.
There was also the fact that Mr Iliopoulos was arrested by City of London Police on the evening of 12 April 2016. He was questioned for some hours as part of an investigation into conspiracy to commit fraud before being released on bail.

It will be interesting to see what happens next in this long running saga. As matters stand the claim remains struck out and it is not clear if owners intend to appeal. It also remains to be seen whether the claim of Piraeus Bank, the second claimant, will proceed to trial in London and whether Mr Iliopoulos will proceed with a defamation claim against the underwriters in Greece.

All in all this is a fascinating case and we will continue to keep our followers advised of developments.

BDM is a specialist shipping law firm offering high quality legal advice and representation at a reasonable price. Please follow us on social media by clicking below.

Other Recent Blogs

  • BDM supports launch of third edition of Shipping and the Environment | BDM Blog | BDM Law
    March 9, 2023

    BDM supports launch of third edition of Shipping and the Environment

    We were delighted to support Colin, Charles and Jonathan at the launch of the third edition of this weighty tome. Environmental regulation is one of the main challenges faced by shipping and all those engaged in the shipping industry. This book is not just about oil spills. [...]

    Read more >
  • BDM and London P&I attend Six Nations | BDM Blog | BDM Law
    February 15, 2023

    BDM and London P&I attend Six Nations

    David McInnes and Joshua Geesing of BDM Law were pleased to attend the Six Nations match between England and Italy alongside Simon Leslie and Simon Chapman of London P&I Club. BDM Law are committed to the Italian market and continue to service a large number of clients b[...]

    Read more >
  • 2023 and what to expect | BDM Blog | BDM Law
    February 9, 2023

    2023 and what to expect

    It’s difficult to predict what lies ahead but it’s illuminating to revisit what we said at the beginning of 2022. By and large, we were right to say that 2022 would be a strong year for shipping and ship owners. The predicted rise in ship casualties has not quite materia[...]

    Read more >
+44 203 968 0500
+44 7887 710 950