Office: +44 203 968 0500
24/7 Emergency Response: +44 7887 710 950
Select Page

Supreme Court to hear Owners’ appeal in CMA Libra case

Supreme Court to hear Owners’ appeal in CMA Libra case - BDM Blog - BDM Law

In late July the Supreme Court gave the ship owners permission to appeal the Court of Appeal’s unanimous decision in The CMA CGM Libra (1).

Whilst the facts of this case are extensive, the main point of consideration is how to differentiate crew negligence (for which there is a defence under the Hague / Hague Visby Rules) and unseaworthiness (for which there is no defence if there is a failure to exercise due diligence).

To date both the High Court and Court of Appeal have taken the view that the master’s failure to correct the passage plan before setting out from a port in China had the result of making the vessel unseaworthy. The owners’ position remains that the crew’s decision as to what to mark on the chart was a navigational decision and this is covered by the navigational error defence. It will be interesting to hear the Supreme Court’s view on the matter. The hearing is scheduled for sometime in late 2021 and we will keep our followers updated.

  1. Alize 1954 & another v.  Allianz Elementar Versicherung AG & Others (The CMA CGM LIBRA) [2020] EWCA Civ 293
BDM is a specialist shipping law firm offering high quality legal advice and representation at a reasonable price. Please follow us on social media by clicking below.

Other Recent Blogs

  • Tendering NOR does wirelessinclude email | BDM Blog | BDM Law
    November 21, 2022

    Tendering NOR – does “wireless” include email?

    In a recent arbitration under the LMAA Small Claims Procedure (1) the Tribunal had to determine the validity of a Notice of Readiness (“NOR”) which had been tendered by email. The NOR is one of the most important documents for ship owners because it acts as a trigger to [...]

    Read more >
  • Delivery without original bills – an example of what can go wrong | BDM Blog | BDM Law
    November 7, 2022

    Delivery without original bills – an example of what can go wrong

    Readers of our blog may recall an article we released back in November 2020 in which we highlighted the risks that a ship owner is required to undertake when accepting a letter of indemnity (LOI) in exchange for releasing the cargo without the production of an original bill [...]

    Read more >
  • Supreme Court gives permission to appeal in The Polar | BDM Blog | BDM Law
    October 31, 2022

    Supreme Court gives permission to appeal in “The Polar”

    We previously reported on the High Court and Court of Appeal’s decisions in one of the last Somali ransom cases still in the Court system. The Court of Appeal held that a war risks provision in a charterparty did not constitute an agreement that the owners would not claim [...]

    Read more >
+44 203 968 0500
+44 7887 710 950