Tendering NOR – does “wireless” include email?

Tendering NOR does wirelessinclude email | BDM Blog | BDM Law

In a recent arbitration under the LMAA Small Claims Procedure (1) the Tribunal had to determine the validity of a Notice of Readiness (“NOR”) which had been tendered by email.

The NOR is one of the most important documents for ship owners because it acts as a trigger to start laytime or the free time available to the charterer to load or discharge. We see many cases where the validity of the NOR is contested. In some cases, the party tendering the NOR (usually the ship owner) makes mistakes and the charterer thus gets more free time.

In this case, the ship owners claimed demurrage. The charterers argued that the NOR tendered at the discharge port was invalid such that time did not start to run until discharge actually commenced.

Clause 6 of the charterparty (which was based on an amended Asbatankvoy form) provided that the master was to tender the NOR “by letter, telegraph, wireless or telephone”. The master tendered his NOR by email.

Charterers argued (with some force) that “wireless” in clause 6 referred to VHF/radio transmissions and that the Asbatankvoy form predated the use of email. The owners contended that the email by which the master tendered the NOR was transmitted wirelessly via the vessel’s wireless communication system. They also denied that email did not exist in 1977 when the Asbatankvoy form was originally published.

The Tribunal accepted the owners’ submissions and held that tendering the NOR by email was permissible under clause 6. The owners’ claim therefore succeeded.

This decision serves as a helpful reminder to owners that they must tender the NOR strictly in accordance with the terms of the charterparty, which includes tendering via one of the methods stipulated in the charterparty. As with so many of these cases, the devil is in the detail. A careful reading might have led to the owners sending the NOR by letter as a back-up so avoiding any basis for a dispute.

  1. London Arbitration 30/22
Benita Cheung - author profile
Benita Cheung
Managing Associate
BDM is a specialist shipping law firm offering high quality legal advice and representation at a reasonable price. Please follow us on social media by clicking below.

Other Recent Blogs

  • Who’s Who Legal 2022 BDM partners selected for recognition | BDM Blog | BDM Law
    November 21, 2023

    Who’s Who Legal 2023: BDM partners selected for recognition

    We are pleased that, once again, our founding partners all appear as leading shipping lawyers in the Who’s Who Legal: Transport 2023 guide. This year Nick Burgess also appears as a “thought leader” which has given him pause for thought! The guide is based on independen[...]

    Read more >
  • Marine Claims Dublin 2023 | BDM Blog | BDM Law
    October 9, 2023

    Marine Claims Dublin 2023

    It was a pleasure to moderate the panel discussion on claims trends over the last year. Many thanks go to my fellow panellists Francesco Zolezzi, Ruby Hassan and Victor Fenwick. Thanks also to the organisers for arranging such a splendid residential course with lots of chanc[...]

    Read more >
  • BDM ranked again it the Legal 500 | BDM Blog | BDM Law
    October 5, 2023

    BDM ranked again in the Legal 500

    Once again we must convey our thanks to all those who helped us to retain our ranking as a leading shipping firm in this year’s Legal 500 rankings. Particular thanks go to those who said such nice things about us, including the below comment which sums up what we consider [...]

    Read more >
+44 203 968 0500
+44 7887 710 950