What happens where the Owner successfully defends a cargo claim and suffered unrecoverable legal costs? Can he pursue a claim against his charterer for those costs under the ICA?

The Inter Club Agreement – just what is a “similar amendment” and why is it important| BDM Blog | BDM LawAccording to a recent LMAA decision*, the answer to the above is “No”.

The tribunal was asked to consider whether the owners, having successfully defended a cargo claim in Belgian court proceedings, were entitled to recover their legal costs from the charterers under the Inter-Club Agreement (the “ICA”).

The underlying cargo claim was dismissed by a final judgment of the Cour de Cassation in Belgium in February 2012. The owners faced a formidable claimant and, consequently, they incurred unrecoverable legal costs in the sum of EUR66,961.   They commenced arbitration proceedings to recover this sum from the charterers in arbitration proceedings. One of the grounds was whether the owners could recover half of this amount under clause 8(d) of the ICA.

Clause (3) of the ICA makes it clear that legal costs reasonably incurred in the defence of or in the settlement of the underlying claim can be included in the cargo claim when seeking apportionment.

Considering owners’ request, the tribunal remarked that the main purpose of the ICA was to provide a relatively simple mechanism to apportion liability for cargo claims between owners and charterers. With this in mind and reflecting upon the wording of clause (8), which contains the key provisions in relation to the apportionment of liability, they considered that liability to a third party had necessarily to be involved. This view was reinforced by clause (4)(c) which requires as a condition precedent to a right to indemnity that a claim has been properly settled or compromised and paid. In the tribunal’s view, clause (3) of the ICA had to be read in the light of those considerations, and consequently a claim for the costs of successfully defending a cargo claim was not intended to be covered. Accordingly, it was held that costs should lie where they fell, in this case with the owners and their P&I Club.

This award highlights the adverse consequences in relation to costs under the ICA when a defendant does not settle and subsequently goes on to win the case.   Some might say that the decision is suspect as this effectively encourages a defendant to consider settlement of a spurious claim purely on the basis that this would leave the way open for a recovery of costs under the ICA. In our view this is an area worthy of judicial consideration but it remains to be seen whether this case will find its way to the High Court on appeal.

*LMLN 10/15 – London Arbitration 10/15 (2015) 929 LMLN 4

BDM is a specialist shipping law firm offering high quality legal advice and representation at a reasonable price. Please follow us on social media by clicking below.

Other Recent Blogs

  • Who’s Who Legal 2022 BDM partners selected for recognition | BDM Blog | BDM Law
    November 21, 2023

    Who’s Who Legal 2023: BDM partners selected for recognition

    We are pleased that, once again, our founding partners all appear as leading shipping lawyers in the Who’s Who Legal: Transport 2023 guide. This year Nick Burgess also appears as a “thought leader” which has given him pause for thought! The guide is based on independen[...]

    Read more >
  • Marine Claims Dublin 2023 | BDM Blog | BDM Law
    October 9, 2023

    Marine Claims Dublin 2023

    It was a pleasure to moderate the panel discussion on claims trends over the last year. Many thanks go to my fellow panellists Francesco Zolezzi, Ruby Hassan and Victor Fenwick. Thanks also to the organisers for arranging such a splendid residential course with lots of chanc[...]

    Read more >
  • BDM ranked again it the Legal 500 | BDM Blog | BDM Law
    October 5, 2023

    BDM ranked again in the Legal 500

    Once again we must convey our thanks to all those who helped us to retain our ranking as a leading shipping firm in this year’s Legal 500 rankings. Particular thanks go to those who said such nice things about us, including the below comment which sums up what we consider [...]

    Read more >
+44 203 968 0500
+44 7887 710 950